Top twenty WWII films

The Guardian recently ran an article on the ten best World War II films, as voted by respondents to a Deltapoll for The War Movie Theatre podcast (see their list and link at the end of this piece).

As this year is 80 years since the end of hostilities, I thought it might be interesting to run down my top twenty World War II films. Here we go:

20. Empire of the Sun (Steven Spielberg - 1987)

This China-set drama of expats during the war in the Pacific theatre was Christian Bale's first big role at the age of 13. He's pretty bloody good too, as are most of the cast, including John Malkovich and Nigel Havers. Spielberg saw this J.G. Ballard story as a chance to make a comparatively 'darker' film about the loss of innocence and it turned out to be one of his very best.

19. The English Patient (Anthony Minghella - 1996)

All the press for this film was the love story angle between dreamy Ralph Fiennes (pre-Voldemort, of course) and elegantly icy Kristin Scott-Thomas, but I found the stuff with Juliette Binoche and Naveen Andrews to be more interesting. A fine film, split into two distinct parts - before and after Fiennes becomes the titular patient.

18. Persian Lessons (Vadim Perelman - 2020)

A fantastically absurd, but possibly true, story of a Jewish prisoner who escapes death by pretending he can speak Persian (he's captured with a Persian book given to him earlier). A camp commandant (the fantastic Lars Eidinger) who wants to move to Iran after the war tasks the prisoner, Reza (Nahuel Perez Biscayart) with teaching him the language. A cat and mouse game of suspicion and incredible tension ensues.

17. Das Boot (Wolfgang Petersen - 1981)

It's been a long time since I've seen this but I recall an intense feeling of dread, brought on by the claustrophobic conditions of the 'boot' (the submarine) where the action takes place. Happily, you can watch this in many different ways, including an extended mini-series (of 300 minutes). An intriguing view of the maritime war from a German perspective.

16. The Dirty Dozen (Robert Aldrich - 1967)

Check out this mint premise - twelve criminals are sent behind enemy lines to kill a bunch of high ranking German officers. Any that return will have their sentences commuted. The original Suicide Squad. Lee Marvin, Ernest Borgnine, Donald Sutherland, Telly Savalas and George Kennedy don't muck about either. A great, hard-arsed romp.

15. Rome, Open City (Roberto Rossellini - 1945)

A staggering achievement, this was made in the dying days of war in Italy, just months after Rome had changed hands. It was directed by Rossellini, co-written by Federico Fellini and starred Anna Magnani - all legends of Italian cinema, and this film went some way to making them so. In a touch of great coincidental timing for Perth folk, the Revelation Film Festival is having one screening only of this classic in July at the Luna.

14. Inglourious Basterds (Quentin Tarantino - 2009)

A return to peak Tarantino for me, this is such a juicy counter-factual reimagining of WWII, with great performances from Christoph Waltz, Diane Kruger Mélanie Laurent and Brad Pitt. Some of the scenes are already in the pantheon - Waltz's calm interrogation in the opening and Michael Fassbender in the basement bar. Electric stuff.

13. Escape to Victory (John Huston - 1981)

Silly fluff and nonsense (Sly Stallone as a goalkeeper!?) about a football match between a strong German team and a motley bunch of POWs. Only these POWs include Pelé, Ossie Ardiles and Bobby Moore, not to mention Michael Caine, all directed by the masterly John Huston. It's ludicrous, dated and heaps of fun.

12. From Here to Eternity (Fred Zinnemann - 1953)

This supremely well-tooled romantic drama, set at the time of the Pearl Harbour attacks, hoovered up the Oscars, with wins for Best Picture, director Zinnemann, supporting actors, Donna Reed and Ol Blue Eyes himself, Frank Sinatra, as well as editing, screenplay, sound and cinematography. Booty. It actually really holds up as a gripping piece of old Hollywood.

11. Downfall (Oliver Hirschbiegel - 2004)

Forget all the memes, this is the duck's guts. Bruno Ganz imbues Hitler with the requisite menace and instability, and Bernd Eichinger's script is nuanced enough, all things considered. This had a fair few brickbats thrown at it upon release but the filmmakers have done us all a favour by bringing us this difficult, but absorbing watch.

10. Ice Cold in Alex (J. Lee Thompson - 1958)

This maybe isn't as well known as some of the others on the list but it's a true lesson in stoicism. John Mills plays the captain of a medical army crew that have gotten themselves separated from the rest of the convoy heading across the North African desert to Alexandria. They pick up a South African officer on the way but things don't quite go to plan. This is a rousing mystery adventure flick in a theatre of war not always seen on film. Cracking 'boys own' stuff.

9. Merry Christmas, Mr. Lawrence (Nagisa Ôshima - 1983)

A fantastic internal war film with an odd but very effective 'musical' pairing of David Bowie and Ryuichi Sakamoto in two of the lead roles. Mainly set in a Japanese POW camp, it's all about hidden desires, betrayals and clashes of culture. Also significant for the memorably stunning theme from Sakamoto.

8. Europa Europa (Agnieszka Holland - 1990)

The only woman director on the list (a discussion to be had there), Holland has delivered an astonishing true life story of a young German Jew who saved himself by joining the Hitler Youth. Fascinating, almost absurd look at the plight of European Jews, the film even flirts with black comedy at times. A fine film from an underrated director (see her excellent Olivier, Olivier).

7. The Zone of Interest (Jonathan Glazer - 2023)

The most recent film on the list, this Auschwitz-based family drama (!) was the best I saw in 2024. Glazer is one of those singular talents (see above) whose films transcend genre and the audacity of some scenes still resonates in my brain. Sandra Hüller and Christian Friedel are superb as the mother and father, and the music and cinematography are top notch. Unflinchingly brilliant.

6. Stalag 17 (Billy Wilder - 1953)

A classic Hollywood POW camp film with a fine cast and an equally great director. US airmen detained behind enemy lines come to suspect that one of their number is an informant. An Oscar-winning performance from William Holden (who also appears higher on this list) and hard-boiled direction from Wilder make this a cut above most POW films (but crucially, not all).

5. The Tin Drum (Volker Schlöndorff - 1979)

Winning the Palme d'Or AND the Best Foreign Language film Oscar doesn't always guarantee greatness but it most certainly does here. Based on the Günter Grass novel, this weird, funny, sad film sees little Oscar (David Bennent) refuse to grow up in protest at all the dickheaded adults around him. Gob-smacking doesn't quite sum up this amazing, surreal film. Seek it out.

4. Casablanca (Michael Curtiz - 1942)

It really shouldn't have worked but credit to Curtiz, writers Koch and the Epsteins, Bogey and Bergman, as well as that unforgettable tune, 'As Time Goes By'. Rick (Bogart) runs a club in Casablanca, the Moroccan city nominally ruled over by the Germans. His idea is to stay neutral for the war's duration, look out for himself and make some coin while doing so. The reappearance of ex-lover Ilsa (Bergman), and her resistance hero husband, scuppers those plans. An outstanding piece of cinema. Propaganda never looked so good.

3. Dunkirk (Christopher Nolan - 2017)

A mesmerising display of filmmaking from a modern master. The ever-decreasing circles of time drive this film to a point and then slowly unravel again. The performances are restrained but stellar from a cast including Tom Hardy, Cillian Murphy, Kenneth Branagh, Barry Keoghan, Mark Rylance - but the real force of the film is the structure. Nolan has wizarded a classic, it's hard to go past this as his best ever.

2. The Bridge on the River Kwai (David Lean - 1957)

One of Lean's many masterpieces, this is almost unbearably tense, especially the fantastic climax. Based on Pierre Boulle's novel, which was itself loosely based on the construction of the Burma Railway, the film deals with the pride and sense duty of Allied prisoners of the Japanese. William Holden (making a habit of getting locked up in films) stars alongside the majestic Alec Guinness (a full 20 years before Obi-Wan Kenobi), and there has rarely been a more chalk and cheese pairing on screen, to the film's great benefit. Classy and timeless, this would be the best WWII film, if not for....

1. The Great Escape (John Sturges - 1963)

Here it is. Cinematic perfection. It's not only the best WWII film, for me, it's the best film ever made. This opinion is just that, an opinion, and I reckon it stems from seeing it so many times in my youth on TV in the 80s. But it really is a stirring, emotional behemoth, juggling action, pathos, comedy, tension, thrills and heart, all backed by Elmer Bernstein's incredible score. Doesn't hurt to have some of the best actors of the time starring either - Charles Bronson, James Garner, James Coburn, Donald Pleasance, Gordon Jackson, Richard Attenborough and the Cooler King, Steve McQueen. A fine adaptation of Paul Brickhill's book by James Clavell, and unfussy, solid direction by Sturges make The Great Escape a peerless work all round.

[Just to top and tail things, the best film about the build up to WWII is Cabaret (1972), and the best film about post-WWII is The Third Man (1949).]

Here's the link to the Guardian story

The full top 10 list, according to the War Movie Theatre podcast poll, was as follows:

1. Dunkirk (2017)

2. Saving Private Ryan (1998)

3. The Great Escape (1963)

4. The Dam Busters (1955)

5. Battle of Britain (1969)

6. The Longest Day (1962)

7. A Bridge Too Far (1977)

8. Pearl Harbor (2001)

9. Schindler’s List (1993)

10. The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957)

Comments

It Was Just an Accident

The latest from Iranian director Jafar Panahi is a simple, yet brilliant story of a chance encounter with a bastard from the past that oscillates between revenge and forgiveness. We start on an almost uncomfortably close mid-shot of a man and a woman driving at night. They run over a stray dog and the mother explains to her daughter that it was just an accident, setting the stage for other events that may or may not have been accidental. Panahi fills the frame with his protagonists, faces, mostly in states of distress, to the extent that when the screen opens up to show a man digging a makeshift grave in a long shot with vast, lumpy hills in the distance, it's a massive relief of tension. This man is Vahid (Vahid Mobasseri), who thinks he has stumbled upon Eghbal, (A.K.A. Peg Leg or the Gimp) (Ebrahim Azizi), an Iranian intelligence agent who tortured him years ago. Doubt forces Vahid to enlist other victims to help identify Peg Leg, before any retribution is taken. The film is rid...

Wake Up Dead Man

Wake Up Dead Man (without a comma to be seen) is the third Benoit Blanc mystery, written and directed by Rian Johnson. Daniel Craig stars again as the Foghorn Leghorn-twanging detective but he's a touch overshadowed here by the 'supporting' cast, namely Josh O'Connor as young priest, Jud (Judas anyone?) Duplenticy, Josh Brolin as Monsignor Wicks and Glenn Close as church dogsbody Martha. Though it seems O'Connor is the new big thing, especially in indie films, I find him about as engaging as the weekly supermarket trip. In saying that, he's a pretty good foil for the rest of the characters, who have charisma by the bucketload. Blanc only appears around the start of act two, after all the set-up has been dealt with, in a very similar fashion to the previous films, Knives Out and Glass Onion . We gather that somebody has been killed on Good Friday, and the format for this exposition is a letter that Blanc asks Jud to write to him. This works well enough, (Keigo ...

Predator: Badlands

So without me really noticing, this franchise has reached NINE films (if you include the two Alien vs Predator crossovers). The last three have been directed (or co-directed) by Dan Trachtenberg, who's also helmed an episode each of the TV shows Black Mirror and The Boys . I've got to say, carry on lad, because this is probably the best Predator film I've seen (let me revisit the Arnie one before I remove that 'probably'). This film starts as a revenge quest that soon morphs into a discourse on dysfunctional families and finding your groove in life. All wrapped up in a gnarly, bloody sci-fi romp. I say blood, in actual fact, none of it is human blood, all characters being either alien or synthetic humanoid. That in itself is one of the film's credits - none of the protagonists are human, and the nominal lead is usually a villain. Dek (Dimitrius Schuster-Koloamatangi) is from the Yautja race, the original 'ugly mother-fucker' Predator. The preamble n...

Hesitation Wound

This film was shown at the Revelation Film Festival programme launch for 2024. It's a Turkish legal drama that leaves a lot unsaid, unexplained, with plenty of scope for interpretation. Tülin Özen plays Canan, a lawyer tasked with defending a guy on a murder charge, Musa (Ogulcan Arman Uslu). At the same time, she is dealing with the slow demise of her old mother, hospitalised in a coma. The minutiae of life in this small Turkish town is fascinating. There's one simple, prosaic scene where Canan stops by a chemist to buy a razor so Musa can shave for the hearing. The shopkeeper asks what kind, she tells him she doesn't know, he selects for her, then explains that she can't use her debit card for that amount, so she buys some pretzel sticks. Completely normal, yet for some reason, I've remembered this scene weeks later. Maybe it's the unusualness of seeing a Turkish store on screen, but I think the on-point pacing of the film has a lot to do with it. Another odd...

The Quiet Girl

This is a great film, especially in the way that it manages to create something interesting out of a reasonably mundane synopsis. A young girl is sent away to a relative's house for the summer where she is treated better than at home. Sounds like it could have a bit of Rohmer-style youthful awakenings? Or maybe some gritty Loach-ian societal comment? Even perhaps a revenge tinged 'fear the youth' theme? Well, it's none of the above, and more power to its style. The Quiet Girl herself (Cáit) is a newcomer, Catherine Clinch, and she was apparently found via an Irish language school call out. She's incredible - meek, direct, no airs nor graces whatsoever, with a clear-eyed awkwardness. She's almost like a little female Bowie in The Quiet Girl Who Fell to Earth (no, not a film but I thought I'd italicise anyway). There are orbiting performances that complement her perfectly. Carrie Crowley and Andrew Bennet play Eibhlín and Seán Cinnsealach, the couple who tak...

Upon Open Sky

Upon Open Sky sees a trio of teenagers head north from Mexico City on a mission to find the trucker who caused the accident that killed the father of the two lads. Promising enough premise, unfortunately, this is a slight film, aiming for profundity. It opens with the build up to the accident, somewhere in the dusty Mexican bush, then the crash itself acts as a timeslip point to two years later. Fernando (Máximo Hollander) scours a car scrapyard, looking for something. His younger brother, Salvador (Theo Goldin), who was in the car when their father died, understandably mopes around the house, only rising to perv on their new step-sister, Paula (Federica Garcia) as she changes for bed. When mum and new step-dad announce they're off to Spain for a holiday, Fernando makes plans of his own to find (and maybe kill) the trucker. So off they go to a town on the US border in search of him. Now, this film could have been much better, and I'm kind of at pains to work out why I didn...

The Secret Agent

Brazilian writer/director Kleber Mendonça Filho delivers one of the films of the year with this political thriller that hoovered up awards at Cannes. It stars Wagner Moura as Armando, an ex-academic who lands in Recife during Carnival time in 1977. Once there, he's welcomed into a kind of apartment block commune, filled with other 'refugees' from some tyranny or other. The opening of the film teases the situation, slowly unpicking the threads as we cruise through the northern Brazilian setting. It's extremely confident of keeping details held back, no need to rush the exposition. We're introduced to quite a few characters, on both sides of humanity - helpful matriarchs, corrupt cops, selfless in-laws, scuzzy hitmen, crusading journos, and one Jewish German Holocaust survivor. Yep, there's a lot going on here. Around the end of the first act, we flash-forward to the present to find a couple of researchers going through old cassette tapes of interviews between Arm...

One Battle After Another

Before this film, Paul Thomas Anderson had at least one certifiable classic on his CV in There Will Be Blood . Now, make that two. In saying this, most of his films range from good to brilliant. This is his second adaptation of a Thomas Pynchon novel (after the uneven but interesting Inherent Vice ) and it looks at the lives of modern American revolutionaries, notably members of French 75. The group are apparently named after a WWI weapon, and then a cocktail, both of which have something of a kick. Leonardo DiCaprio plays Bob, The Rocket Man, who makes the ordnance for the group and is in a relationship with fellow revolutionary, Perfidia (Teyana Taylor). A combination of a run-in with Sean Penn's Colonel Steven Lockjaw, and a rash killing of a security guard triggers more interest in the group, and so a roundup begins. Perfidia is caught, then forced to name names before doing a runner. But not before she has a daughter with Bob, whom he is left to raise on the run. After this f...

The Fantastic Four: First Steps

A few years ago, we hit the S.S.P. (Superhero Saturation Point). And the best way for studios to arrest, or even maybe reverse, the law of diminishing returns is to JUST GIVE IT A FUCKING REST. There's enough residual goodwill in the fan base to guarantee profits....for now. But, as Malcolm Gladwell said, there must be a tipping point. So into this cinematic avalanche slips The Fantastic Four: First Steps , the first film of Phase Six and the thirty seventh overall! It's quite dull for the first 30 minutes, setting up the characters, ensuring the audience understands we're on a slightly different Earth (828), and a different time as well. It only gets going when the Silver Surfer (Julia Garner) appears and promises everyone death by devouring. She's not going to eat them, she works for a massive space turd called Galactus, played by Finchy himself, Ralph Ineson. He'll do the devouring. Here's the thing - this film is a perfectly serviceable entry, not brilliant,...

Nouvelle Vague

This opening screening of the Perth Festival's Lotterywest Film season is a cinephile's delight. It documents the production of Jean-Luc Godard's seminal feature debut, À Bout de Souffle (or Breathless ). The title refers to the New Wave of French film from the beginning of the 1960s, which railed against the tired, old ways of film-making. Nouvelle Vague actually looks like it was shot on film, it's riddled with scratch marks, there's are many big black dots indicating the end of the reel, and of course, it's in black and white. The director, Richard Linklater, is obviously a huge fan of Breathless . This is a lovingly made, breezy film, that isn't terribly hard-hitting or deep, but is a fine background to one of the classics. The casting is excellent, specifically the Jeans; Godard, Seberg and Belmondo, played by Guillaume Marbeck, Zoey Deutch and Aubry Dullin respectively. They all look the part and turn in performances just the right side of parody....

Film Shapes

Search This Blog